Flourishing Life Society
  • Flourishing Life Society
    • Addiction Recovery
    • Books to Flourish
    • Human Flourishing
    • Mindfulness Archive
    • Personal Development >
      • Personal Development Archive
    • Non-Profit Donation Links
  • Psychology of Wellness
    • Basic Emotions >
      • Emotional Data Base
      • Emotional Fitness
    • Psychology Article Archive
  • Flourishing Relationships
    • Intimate Relationship Articles >
      • Repair Attempts
    • Society and Others Archive >
      • Politics Archive
  • Health and Fitness
  • About Us
  • Link Page
Flourishing Life | Personal Development | Am I Selfish?

Am I Selfish?

Selfish Motivations Behind Kind Acts

BY: T. Franklin Murphy  | January 2014 (edited December 28, 2021)
A man and a woman looking at each other wearing masks. A Flourishing Life Society article on motivations behind acts of kindness
Stock Adobe Royalty Free Images
Our subjective judgments may soften selfish motivations, sweetening the sour, and ignoring the bitter. We can do better. We can be compassionate because we care.
Compassion and meanness appear to the casual observer as opposites. We believe identifying one from the other is simple—obvious without taking time to discern the difference. Compassion is good and meanness is bad, right? A popular bumper sticker sums it up well, “Mean People Suck.” Compassion is essential for flourishing. Simple enough—we should be compassionate. But we lose objectivity when observing behaviors in ourselves, judging personal characteristics is never simple. Compassion is more than blatant kindness, the complexity can be murky, confused by biased assessments. Our noble acts of kindness may not be all that noble. Perhaps, we are driven by a need to please. In all our self-righteous goodness, underneath we just maybe—selfish

Motivations Behind the Act

We judge our compassion from select behavioral expressions, we conveniently filter for neatness, while ignoring the dark motivations bubbling underneath. Behaviors may appear compassionate but the action, perhaps, was motivated by hope for personal gain. Or conversely, a behavior may appear spiteful but compassionately motivated.
​
Compassionate people are sensitive to suffering—all suffering.  Benevolent internal stirrings encourage action to assuage the observed pain; a motivating affect starts the movement towards kindness. 

Giving to Avoid a Fight

Giving a grown child money may not be an act of compassion if the gift is knowingly contributing to a nasty drug habit. We may be giving money to avoid another conflict. The discomfort motivating action isn't sensitivity to suffering but fear of another dramatic encounter with a disrespectful adult child. Relieving guilt or protective maneuvers isn’t compassion. The money is given for self-benefiting reasons—not necessarily wrong, just not an act of compassion.

The complexity of hidden motivations, pushing actions, allows us manipulate the reason behind our action. Just as kindness may be selfishly motivated, appearances of meanness may actually be acts of  compassion. Grabbing the arm of the toddler about to jet across the busy street may upset the youngster, his plans were foiled. But the act may have saved his life, whether he understands the purpose of the intervention or not.
"The complexity of hidden motivations, pushing actions, allows us manipulate the reason behind our action."

No Gauge to Measure Compassion

Lengthy and adept justifications can manipulate both good and bad actions, treating the mind to the enjoyable meaning it seeks. Mean people don’t see themselves as such. Mean people shiftily explain evil with a positive twist. “I am a straight shooter; I say things as they are,” or “Karma, they just got what they deserved.” Our explanations may be accurate or justifying—depending on the context.  Our straight shooting may be hurtful, not spoken with concern, but with venom.
 
There is no gauge available to measure compassion; no ruler, no scale. We must rely on the imperfect subjective reasoning of our minds, doing our best to look a little deeper, considering common tendencies to justify with a rosy picture. Kindness that we give or receive when carefully examined may reveal unseen factors—social acceptance, insecurity, financial benefits, votes, or self-promotion.

Kindness motivated by outside forces, with expectant strings attached, may quietly (or overtly) demand payback. No compassion is found here. When we express kindness because we feel obligated or with hopes of reward, we feel slighted when no reward is given. When the motivating purpose is to alleviate someone's pain, the act is its own reward.

Any kindness, no matter the motivations, isn’t necessarily wrong; it just isn’t compassion and we would do well to acknowledge it as such.

Insecurities and Selfish Protections

When insecurities are strong—as it is for many–we seek acceptance, often with acts of kindness. Such acts reward with superficial acceptance. But the actions, foolishly motivated for personal gain are often remembered, like bills for services rendered. When left unpaid, the kindness is withdrawn, self-righteousness glorified, and the receiver vilified. "I was kind and you never gave anything in return!" Gifts, under these rules, are given but not freely, later presented as evidence against the receiver.

​Kindness with strings attached are not gifts, but bartering tools for personal gains.
 
Cooperation is essential for intimacy, diplomacy and survival. Kindness may always contain a measure of selfishness. Self-interest is part of survival. But selfishness must be diluted with recognition of the value of others. When acts are inspired with compassion, the kindness connects us to the whole.

​For the compassionate joys are less palatable when only obtained by stealing joy from another. Some enjoy winning, while other prefer beating others. With compassion, we are willing to suffer if it brings relief to the whole.

​We must skeptically examine actions for hidden evil motives. We can be more objective, a little more compassionate, eliminating suffering and promoting greater kindness.
 
Compassion is not always joyful. Compassion may cause sorrow when we connect with the pain of another. Our success our tempered by the costs to the whole. Compassion stimulates sorrow for suffering and feel motivated to help relieve. With compassion, exposures to crime and poverty, even by people in a foreign lands, chills our soul and we feel sad.

Our well-being requires processing these uncomfortable feelings without ignoring suffering by dismissing their pain with blame and division. Often, we prefer to escape the discomforts by proclaiming, "they bring it on themselves." But pain is real and hurts regardless of the cause. I ask, check yourselves closely, asking point blank with no excuses, "am I selfish?"
Please support Flourishing Life Society with a social media share or by visiting a link:
Twitter Reddit LinkedIn Email
T. Franklin Murphy
T. Franklin Murphy
Wellness. Writer. Researcher.
​T. Franklin Murphy has a degree in psychology. He tirelessly researches scientific findings that contribute to wellness. In 2010, he began publishing his findings.

Index:

Flourishing in Life
  • Personal Development
  • Addiction Recovery
  • Wellness 
Psychology of Wellness
  • Emotions​
  • Personality
  • Defense Mechanisms
Flourishing Relationships
  • Intimate
  • Parent/Child
  • Society
Health and Fitness
Key Word Archives
Research
About Flourishing Life
Flourishing Life Society Link to research articles
Banner link to Flourishing Life Society's Personal development articles
Wellness Links
External Link: 5 Small Morning Habits To Set You Up for a Happy Day
External Link: How To Become A Little Happier In Difficult Times
External Link: Want to ditch a bad habit? Then just take it one day at a time
External Link: Does a growth mindset matter for success?
External Link: It’s better to focus on where you are going than how you are feeling
External Link: Why Thinking Small Is Your Best Defense in Tough Situations
External Link: Why We Procrastinate and What To Do About It
External Link: All Our Baby Steps Count
Psychology of Wellness Banner link to Flourishing Life Society articles

​Other Flourishing Life Society articles of interest on this topic:

We unwittingly promote unhealthy defense mechanisms on line. There are plenty pf social media participants willing to support life limiting adaptations.
FLS link. Passionate Purpose. We need passionate purpose to energize our flat lives, giving fire to existence and joy to routines.
Learning comes from more than pages in a book. Living knowledge must be experienced, converting words into actions.
Flourishing Life Society Link. Neuroticism. A personality Trait.
Our environment is instrumental to our mental health. When work or home constantly ignites stress, our systems bog down, and well-being suffers.
Flourishing Life Society article link for Social Desirability Bias
Opptimisitic mindsets can improve our emotions
Internal Link: Working Out Differences. The Key to Relationship Success
Picture
The universe is immense and knowledge abound. We can never understand everything. Our perspective limits our views. We must open to the knowledge of others to escape our subjective prisons.
Flourishing Life Society Link. Sunshine and Mental Health
FLS Link. Liar Liar: Pathological Liar. Pervasive liars destroy relationships and limit personal growth. While the causes of pathological fibbing are complex, we can examine our own honesty and realign with reality.
Flourishing Life Society article link. Deep Reflection
Books, conferences and education are wonderful; but deeper wisdom comes from grander sources.
FLS link. Neuroplasticity and Learning. The Brain and new habits
Flourishing Life Society article link. Stoically Aloof

Flourishing Life Society Article Collections:

Research article archive link
Self-compassion article archive link
Divorce and break-ups article archives
Psychology Theories article archive link
2021 article archive link
Intimate Relationships article archive link
Our subjective judgments may misrepresent our ill-intended motivations, sweetening the sour, and ignoring the bitter. We can do better. We can be compassionate because we care.
Picture
Flourishing Life Society
  • Human Flourishing
  • Psychology of Wellness
  • Flourishing Relationships
  • Psychology Definitions​
​Other Links
  • About US
  • Companion Site​
  • Most Popular Articles
  • Psychology Topics A-z
Articles:
  • New Articles​
  • Last year's Publications​
​Favorites:
  • Self-Actualization
  • Emotional Safety
  • Alexithymia
  • ​Emotional Detachment
  • Masochistic Personality
  • Reciprocal Deteminism ​
News Letter

    New Article Updates

Subscribe to Newsletter
  • Flourishing Life Society
    • Addiction Recovery
    • Books to Flourish
    • Human Flourishing
    • Mindfulness Archive
    • Personal Development >
      • Personal Development Archive
    • Non-Profit Donation Links
  • Psychology of Wellness
    • Basic Emotions >
      • Emotional Data Base
      • Emotional Fitness
    • Psychology Article Archive
  • Flourishing Relationships
    • Intimate Relationship Articles >
      • Repair Attempts
    • Society and Others Archive >
      • Politics Archive
  • Health and Fitness
  • About Us
  • Link Page