Flourishing Life Society
  • Flourishing Life Society
    • Flourishing Favorites
    • Articles by Year Published
    • Privacy Policy
    • About Us
  • Psychology Definitions
  • Psychology of Wellness
    • Psychology of Emotions >
      • Emotional Data Base
    • Psychology Article Archive
  • Personal Development
    • Health and Fitness
    • Personal Development >
      • Personal Development Archive N-Z
  • Flourishing Relationships
Home | Personal Development | Critical Feedback

Critical Feedback

Watching, Listening, Learning

BY: T. Franklin Murphy | June 2018 (edited June 16, 2022)
Two people communicating with discomforting expressions. A Flourishing Life Society article on critical feedback
Adobe Stock Images
Critical feedback devastates the sensitive ego, but defenses prevent learning.
Receiving critical feedback is not easy. The ego intrudes, and criticism feels like rejection. Yet, criticism can be constructive, even when poorly presented, assisting with self-discovery and improvement. If we disregard messages because we perceive them as ignorant and malicious, we may miss golden nuggets of wisdom that is only available from external observations; much critical feedback is only available through others.

Some Feedback Hurts

​Some messages hurt, challenging beliefs, behaviors or dreams. By instinctively disregarding all messages because they challenge our soundness or intelligence, we hobble personal development. Instead of gaining wisdom, we foolishly protect with defensiveness, missing valuable insights that provide opportunities to enhance skills, knowledge, or wisdom.
"Feedback is the breakfast of champions."
Ken Blanchard

Not All Feedback Has Worth

​Not all criticism is valuable. There are false messages with malicious intent. Some insults are born from jealousies and bitterness. Other messages flow from those without helpful experiences, commenting without understanding. These messages give more insight into their character than the subject of their misguided comments.

We Evaluate Source of Feedback

Because faulty messages are possible—and abundant, it’s easy to disregard valuable messages containing rich insights. Wisdom gets lost in the sludge, disregarded by our protective egos. Our naturally competitive states get involved, our insecurities rise to the intrusions and wisdom suffers. We justify our arrogance, fears, and protections by blaming the advice as flawed.
"We all need people who will give us feedback. That's how we improve."
Bill Gates

​However, many sources of feedback are valuable. People with experience and skills may offer thoughtful critiques that help. A valuable message from a trustworthy sources still may be poorly presented. For example, a person may be a masterful engineer but a terrible teacher. Her insight on engineering may be valuable even if her social skills are lacking.

If we want wisdom, we must take time to listen, asking questions to better understand messages being conveyed, guarding against the protective recoiling of our ego. Once the air is cleared of the normal interference, we can mindfully evaluate the message for value. Our humble approach opens the door of a listening heart, we gain wisdom and we create an atmosphere where ideas, knowledge and experience are welcome.
Please support Flourishing Life Society with a social media share or by visiting a link:
Twitter Reddit LinkedIn Email
T. Franklin Murphy
T. Franklin Murphy
Wellness. Writer. Researcher.
​T. Franklin Murphy has a degree in psychology. He tirelessly researches scientific findings that contribute to wellness. In 2010, he began publishing his findings.

Index:

Flourishing in Life
  • Personal Development
  • Mindfulness
  • Addiction Recovery
  • Wellness 
Psychology of Wellness
  • Emotions​
  • Personality
  • Defense Mechanisms
Flourishing Relationships
  • Intimate
  • Parent/Child
  • Society
Health and Fitness
Key Word Archives
Research
About Flourishing Life
Psychology Definitions Data Base Link
Outside Articles:
External Link. Our obsession with happiness is making our kids miserable
External Link:  How to upgrade your mindset for success
External Link: How to engage with life when you feel down
External Link: How My Constant Perfectionism Takes Over My Life
External Link: Unpacking the Power of Privileged Neighborhoods
External Link: Happiness and Authenticity (Part 1)--The Bound Spirit
External Link: Feeling stressed? ‘Safety signals’ might help your brain better cope in the moment
Link: How Humility will make you the greatest person ever

​Other Flourishing Life Society articles of interest on this topic:

Feedback Loops. A Flourishing Life Society article image link
A Flourishing Life Society article link. Fear of Change
Flourishing Life Society article link. Over Analyzing
Opportunity Mindset. Looking for and Taking Advantage of Opportunities. A Flourishing Life Society article link
A Flourishing Life Society link. Entitlement to Ease
FLS Link. The Experience Machine: In 1974, Robert Nozick posed a question. Would you plug into an experience machine that provided all the feelings of desired experience without the struggles of reality?
When we expect uninterrupted joy, life intrudes and we feel depressed. Life is beautiful; but not always.
Faulty Symbols of Success. A Flourishing Life Society article link
Our subjective judgments may misrepresent our ill-intended motivations, sweetening the sour, and ignoring the bitter. We can do better. We can be compassionate because we care.
A Flourishing Life Society article link to Invitations to Change
Keeping on trck when life obstacles interfere
Taking advantage of the fleeting moments of motivation to implement long-term change.
We can change; it's just not easy. Forces pull us in many directions, usually following a set trajectory, moving in the same direction as before. We can adjust but must do so with confidence and skill.
Flourishing Life Society article link. Deep Reflection
Life is governed by laws. Many actions involve several laws competing fro dominance.
Patronizing Advice. The Curious Task of Writing About Wellness. A Flourishing Life Society article Image link
Critical feedback devastates the sensitive ego, but narrowing wisdom to our own experience makes us stupid.
Picture
Flourishing Life Society
  • Human Flourishing
  • Psychology of Wellness
  • Flourishing Relationships
  • Psychology Definitions​
  • Privacy Policy
​Other Links
  • About US
  • Companion Site​
  • Most Popular Articles
  • Psychology Topics A-z
Articles:
  • New Articles​
  • Last year's Publications​
  • External Psychology Links​
​Favorite Topics:
  • Mental Illness Archive
  • Personality Archive
  • Personal Development
  • Psychology of Emotions
News Letter

    New Article Updates

Subscribe to Newsletter
  • Flourishing Life Society
    • Flourishing Favorites
    • Articles by Year Published
    • Privacy Policy
    • About Us
  • Psychology Definitions
  • Psychology of Wellness
    • Psychology of Emotions >
      • Emotional Data Base
    • Psychology Article Archive
  • Personal Development
    • Health and Fitness
    • Personal Development >
      • Personal Development Archive N-Z
  • Flourishing Relationships